New York State judge Nancy M. Bannon recently ordered Fordham University to recognize a chapter of Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP)—a student organization that has become central in the Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS) movement—following a decision by the dean of students, Keith Eldredge, to reject SJP’s application for recognition in the 2016–2017 academic year. The American Council of Trustees and Alumni (ACTA) applauds the court’s decision to uphold the free exchange of ideas.
Mr. Eldredge declined SJP’s application because he felt that activism around the Israeli-Palestinian conflict would lead to “polarization rather than dialogue.” This idea—that college students are unable to discuss certain topics—damages the educational mission of the university. If the academy were to avoid polarizing topics, important research would stop, and the advancement of knowledge would stall. If the dean of students were to protect students from upsetting or controversial issues, the university would be in danger of becoming an extended safe space. As long as Students for Justice in Palestine is scrupulous in obeying campus regulations and respects the rights of pro-Israel organizations, it has a right to express its views and be heard.
That being said, university leadership must be vigilant not to capitulate to demands by Students for Justice in Palestine that violate academic freedom. ACTA warned in its 2017 essay “Campus Free Speech, Academic Freedom, and the Problem of the BDS Movement” that the BDS movement has often posed threats to academic freedom. For example, petitions to ban students from studying abroad in Israel, which infringe upon the academic freedom of students who wish to study there as well as the religious liberty of Jewish students, have become too commonplace on campuses across the nation.
Dr. Michael Poliakoff, President of ACTA, stated, “Fordham University must walk a fine line: It must acknowledge Students for Justice in Palestine and encourage a free and open debate of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, while ensuring that SJP does not obstruct the rights of Jewish or pro-Israel students, or attempt to silence their voices.”
Media Contact: Connor Murnane, Program Officer for Communications
media@goacta.org (202) 467-0376
Chancellor Daniel Diermeier of Vanderbilt University in Tennessee recently warned against the “[p]oliticization of scholarly associations” following the American Association of University Professors’s (AAUP) decision in August to withdraw its opposition to academic boycotts.
Colleges and universities face renewed danger in the coming academic year. There is no doubt that the demonstrators will be back, louder and more determined. They will be better organized, well-funded, and will certainly have legal counsel and media by their side. More campuses will likely be affected. Sadly, the protesters will again show little […]
In late November, Columbia University’s Student Council voted to put the question of whether to recommend that the university divest “from companies that profit from or engage in the State of Israel’s acts towards Palestinians” to a full vote of the undergraduate student body. It was the third time that the council considered a divestment referendum in four […]
Launched in 1995, we are the only organization that works with alumni, donors, trustees, and education leaders across the United States to support liberal arts education, uphold high academic standards, safeguard the free exchange of ideas on campus, and ensure that the next generation receives an intellectually rich, high-quality college education at an affordable price.
Discover MoreSign up to receive updates on the most pressing issues facing our college campuses.