This past November, the American Council of Trustees and Alumni (ACTA) released the second edition of “No U.S. History? How College History Departments Leave the United States out of the Major.” Higher education donors may want to take a look at this report, which reveals the sorry state of American history courses at our nation’s top institutions of higher education. The measurements used are whether a college or university requires a wide-ranging American history course of its history majors and in its general education core. The results are dismal.
The report’s findings show:
If you’re wondering what a “narrow or niche option” might look like, the “History of Mental Health and Mental Illness in the United States” is being offered this semester at Cornell University. At Penn State, a student might be enrolled in an American history course titled “The Consumer Revolution.” And Middlebury College currently offers a course called “Mad Men and Mad Women,” which utilizes “AMC’s Mad Men as a visual and narrative foundation” to “examine masculinity and femininity in mid-20th century America.”
These courses are no doubt interesting and informative and it’s not hard to understand their appeal. Taken alone, however, they will not build the civic literacy necessary to understand the principles that have shaped our republic, the responsibilities of citizenship and the virtue and sacrifice required to defend American history and our freedoms. There may have been a time when institutions of higher education might have reasonably assumed that freshmen would arrive on their campuses with a solid grounding in civics and United States history. Sadly, we know that is no longer the case.
The ACTA report confirms what many critics of the nation’s colleges and universities have argued in recent years — that by shedding a common core of coursework and marginalizing traditional survey courses in American history and Western Civilization, these institutions are contributing to the polarization that currently characterizes our political system. In a January 15 op-ed in The Wall Street Journal, John Ellis, a professor emeritus at the University of California, Santa Cruz, warned that academia’s deleterious impact on our country “will intensify as the number of people who have graduated from radicalized campuses increases and the number of those who graduated with a conventional college education declines.”
In her recent Commentary book review of “Rescuing Socrates,” Naomi Schaefer Riley, resident fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, said the book’s author, Roosevelt Montás, credits the rapidly disappearing core curriculum with transmitting “a range of shared institutions, norms, categories and values in which we all participate and in which we all have a stake.” Montás, a senior lecturer in American Studies at Columbia University, went on to say, “My being a brown immigrant from the Dominican Republic does not make the Constitution less relevant to me than it is to my wife, a white woman born in rural Michigan.”
Donors to institutions of higher education may want to take a hard look at the state of American history at the schools they support and direct their resources in ways that ensure increased attention to our nation’s common legacy and shared values. “No U.S. History?” provides detailed information on over 70 of those colleges and universities.
They also should keep an eye on Philanthropy Roundtable’s Programs team, which has made “America’s Founding Principles” one of its primary focus areas. The identification of organizations and initiatives that defend our founding principles, contribute to a robust civics education and ensure that the needs of members of the military are met after they leave service may provide some stirring examples to bring to our college campuses.
This article originally appeared here.
ACTA has released the second edition of “No U.S. History? How College History Departments Leave the United States out of the Major.” The report found that 18 of the top 25 public universities did not have a wide-ranging American history requirement for students seeking a B.A. in history in the major or core curriculum. Top universities have […]
For six decades, Dr. Gordon S. Wood’s scholarship has advanced the understanding of the formative years of our nation. His work on the American Revolution and the creation of the American Republic is not only renowned for its meticulous accuracy and groundbreaking insight but also for its elegant and effective presentation, which has made it resonate among professional historians and a much wider public.
Why do we teach U.S. history and government to students? The answer is simple: to prepare students for engaged and informed citizenry, the essential ingredient for preserving the American republic. Unfortunately, ACTA’s most recent What Will They Learn?® survey of the core curricula at over 1,100 colleges and universities found that only 18% of institutions require students […]
It can be hard for donors to support higher education in keeping with their values. But there are options at universities all across the country. Americans have never been so disappointed by higher education. In a survey by the Association of American Colleges and Universities and the Bipartisan Policy Center, only 60% of Americans said that they […]
The word deplorable understates the status of civic education at American colleges and universities. But there are new initiatives to address it, some led by trustees, some by legislatures. Such changes are not without controversy, but if an informed electorate matters—and it does—then these programs demand consideration. How bad is our situation? When nearly one-third […]
If “reading maketh a full man,” as Sir Francis Bacon avers, Then the New York Times best-seller list is a window into the American soul. To judge from the view, we are an angry, divided, and shallow nation. A deeper look, however, can give us some hope even in that bleak landscape of elite Americana. One finds […]
Launched in 1995, we are the only organization that works with alumni, donors, trustees, and education leaders across the United States to support liberal arts education, uphold high academic standards, safeguard the free exchange of ideas on campus, and ensure that the next generation receives an intellectually rich, high-quality college education at an affordable price.
Discover MoreSign up to receive updates on the most pressing issues facing our college campuses.